Returning to the subject of a clue for fishcake, and specifically for fish as explained by William.
My suggested clue is
ghoti .....
I remembered that the word ghoti was coined so as to be pronounced the same as fish.
gh as in cough
o as in women
ti as in action
This is nice thinking, but for such an oddball clue (not a derogatory description) I would add some indicator, like the "reportedly" I have used in some solutions posted here.
So it could be: "Reportedly, ghoti came before sponge, maybe, and shaped like one."
Similar indicators are "sounds like" (too obvious) and "heard." Sadly, at this instant I can't think of any others.
I can not usually solve cryptic crossword puzzle either.
Solving them seems to rely on imprecise thinking.
No, solving them relies on precise but lateral thinking. As knowing about your word "ghoti", and putting together sponge and cake.
The normal encyclopaedic clue for fishcake could be something like "Fried seafood patty", but there is little fun in that.